The Truth about Tamoxifen

The Truth about Tamoxifen

Tamoxifen - What´s the Truth?

Women with breast cancer, and even some of those who just want to prevent breast cancer, will know of the Holy Trinity: Tamoxifen, Aromatase Inhibitors and Herceptin the drugs that can fight and even beat breast cancer. 

In this CANCERactive article we cover Tamoxifen (or Tamofen, Nolvadex, or Soltamox). We will cover the benefits of Tamoxifen. And we will cover the dangers, risks and side-effects of Tamoxifen too. 

OESTROGEN - fighting for cellular receptor sites

Oestrogen, or Estrogen in the USA, can be a major driver of breast cancer (and other cancers).  Tests will be conducted to find out whether you are reacting to oestrogen, progesterone or are HER-2 positive. Some women will be triple negative, meaning that none of these three is involved.

Oestrogen is known to drive many breast cancers by causing changes inside healthy cells, by causing stem cells to stay in this rapidly dividing state, and by even causing damaging mutations and epigenetic blockages.

You will hear that ´Oestrogen is the female sex hormone´. Actually, it isn´t. Human oestrogen comes in several forms. Oestrone is the female sex hormone, produced by the C-2 pathway from the ovaries. Oestrogen refers to a family of chemicals, some dangerous, others far less so. The family is in three parts: Human oestrogen; chemical oestrogen; phytoestrogen.

Another human estrogen, Oestradiol, is the dangerous sister - it is produced - in men and women - by aromatase enzymes on the C-16 pathway, principally from the fat stores around the body.

Chemical oestrogens can be absorbed from some pesticides, herbicides and many in-home toiletry, personal care, plastic or detergent products that can act like a dangerous oestrogen, once in your body. These are called Xenoestrogens. CLICK HERE to view a terrific range of Toxin-free products.

There is a third group in the oestrogen family - Plant oestrogens, or phytoestrogens.

Phytoestrogens are far, far weaker than human oestrogen´s and, like Tamoxifen, can bind to and thus block receptor sites from the action of human oestrogen´s.

Typically, you will find phytoestrogens in greens, pulses, flaxseed and mushrooms. However, you need to eat a lot, and eat them every day because they are not as strong in their binding ability and they wash through the body easily. This is why many women choose to juice greens.

Japanese women have been shown to have a much lower incidence of recurrence of breast cancer than Western women because of this - diet and lifestyle were the reasons given by the researchers (Int Radiation Oncol 2005; 62).

You can find out far more about Oestrogen and cancer, and ways of naturally combating it in our article Pillar II Toxins and Oestrogen, one of our 4 Pillars of cancer series.

Tamoxifen and other Breast Cancer Drugs

 1. Tamoxifen is used to block the oestrogen receptor sites on cell membranes. Thus human oestrogens - oestradiol, oestrogen or, chemical oestrogen´s, xenoestrogens, find binding to these sites less easy. 

Unfortunately, tamoxifen is itself a carcinogen. It is known to cause an increased incidence of endometrial or uterine cancer, and is a potent carcinogen in rat liver, where it forms covalent DNA adducts. It was declared a carcinogen by the World Health Organisation in April 1996. However, it is known to reduce the incidence of breast cancer moving to the other breast, and ´officialdom´ concludes that the benefits outweigh the risks. 

You will be given Tamoxifen if you are still pre-menopausal. It may well bring on menopause.

 2. Aromatase inhibitors (AIs) aim to block the production of human oestrogen in your body in the first place. These include Anastrozole (Arimidex); Exemestane (Aromasin) and Letrozole (Femara).  Human oestrogen is principally made in the ovaries pre-menopause, but up to 60 per cent of it can be made in other tissues and the balance changes as you age. Thus AIs are most often used in women who have already reached menopause.

However, there are repeated studies showing the ´best practice´ of 5 years on Tamoxifen then 3 years on Letrozole (or similar) might be wrong. A meta-study covered in The Lancet in October 2015, suggested that AIs were much superior to Tamoxifen (AIs better than Tamoxifen: See Here) reducing mortality by 15 per cent, and secondary endometrial cancer risk. However, they were more likely to cause bone problems.

3. Herceptin: Much work has taken place with women who are neither oestrogen positive (ER+) or Progesterone positive (P+). One ´breakthrough´ was finding a group of women (about 20 per cent of women in total) who were HER-2 positive. About half of these respond positively to a monoclonal antibody called Herceptin.

This seems to work well for several years, but like all drugs, cancer manages to evolve and the drug works less well. A further development is Pertuzumab (Perjeta) which has been shown to extend the ´life´ of Herceptin. In some hospitals both Pertuzumab and Herceptin are prescribed simultaneously.

In 2015 the new drug Tyverb (or in the USA, Tykerb, or Lapatinib) was approved for use with Herceptin. Excited scientists were even claiming the total elimination of some cancers (Tyverb and breast cancer: See HERE). However, several women have reported to us that their UK oncologists have been having no such success with the drug.

Helping reduce your Oestrogen levels naturally

Readers should also look at the benefits of Indole 3 carbinol/DIM, (Go to: A review on Indole 3 carbinol), which can down regulate oestradiol to its safer sisters. The natural compound, derived from foods such as broccoli, also works against non-oestrogenic cancers along the p27 pathway. It can also modify the cell membrane receptor sites to make them less attractive to oestradiol. Some US hospitals are actually prescribing it for ER+ breast cancer patients.

Melatonin, a hormone available as an over the counter supplement outside the EU is also extremely beneficial. Melatonin, is produced by the pineal gland about 1 hour after you fall asleep. It puts you into a deeper sleep. It is now known to be produced by certain healthy gut bacteria. Melatonin is the most powerful antioxidant we produce as animals. It is also very anti-inflammatory, which is why sleep is so healing. Importantly it regulates plasma levels of oestrogen and growth hormone, both drivers of breast cancer 

(Go To: Melatonin - Self-defence against cancer). 

There is research in Cancer Watch that shows sleep (melatonin) helps Tamoxifen work better. Like I3C, melatonin has been shown to regulate the receptor sites stopping oestradiol´s actions; and they both have epigenetic benefits, being able to correct blockages stopping essential DNA message production.

Go To: Melatonin helps chemo work, increases survival, reduces side-effects

Red clover, a herb with the active phytoestrogen genestein, also helps block dangerous human oestrogens.

The City of Hope Hospital in Los Angeles have conducted research on natural aromatase inhibitors and have been giving women one and a half cups of white, button mushrooms which they say contain aromatase inhibiting factors. 

Go to: White button mushrooms help in breast and prostate cancer

Other research we have covered has signalled the importance of good levels of omega 3 and vitamin B-12. In a 2008 study from the University of Toronto, women with good blood levels of magnesium and vitamin D survive far longer than those with deficiencies. And women who take daily exercise double their survival rates.

Approximately, 93% of women with breast cancer were found on diagnosis to be deficient in vitamin D. Worse, other research shows that blood levels of vitamin D are indicative of survival times. Women with low levels survive least. Boston Medical School have been researching vitamin D for over 20 years and recommend people with cancer supplement with 5,000 IUs of vitamin D a day. That would equate to 4 hours on the beach in the sun. A study from Edinburgh University confirmed the importance of vitamin D supplementation.

Go To: Vitamin D supplementation increases breast cancer survival

If you are thinking of buying Vitamin D you might like to look at the Natural Selection Product of Choice. You can do this by clicking here

The actions in breast cancer of Tamoxifen (or, Nolvadex D, Soltamox, Tamofen)

Tamoxifen has been the most commonly prescribed drug in the UK to treat breast cancer since its approval in the 1970s. It is given to both pre- and post-menopausal women. It is given after surgery to prevent breast cancer returning; it is given in advanced cases to reduce spread; and it is given as a preventative supplement to prevent breast cancer in high risk cases. It is still the pre-eminent drug for pre-menopausal oestrogen positive women with breast cancer. It is also given to men with breast cancer.

Tamoxifen has played a huge role in breast cancer treatment and in a 30 per cent reduction in mortality from breast cancer since 1990 despite an increase in incidence. It is normally prescribed for a period of a maximum of 5 years.

Tamoxifen is often described as the anti-oestrogen as the simple explanation for its action has always been that it blocks the oestrogen receptor site on the walls of cells, preventing oestradiol (a dangerous member of the oestrogen family) causing its havoc inside your cells. It is thus prescribed for women who are oestrogen positive (ER+). It will not work if your cancer is not oestrogen positive.

(Readers might also like to read Oestrogen the killer in our midst for tips on how to control oestrogen levels naturally - Go to: Buy Book: Oestrogen - the Killer in our midst)

In blocking oestrogen receptor sites, Tamoxifen helps slow the growth and reproduction of breast cancer cells. In 1998, Tamoxifen became the first drug to be approved by the American FDA to prevent breast cancer after research showed it halved the chances of the disease developing in women at high risk. This may now be seen as an exaggeration. Patients can be assessed individually by their oncologists. Some patients have a forecast survival increment of just 1.5%.

Tamoxifen Research shows it can:

1. Lower breast cancer risk in high-risk women by almost 50 per cent

2. Shrink larger ER+ tumours prior to surgery

3. Slow, or even stop, tumour growth and spread in advanced breast cancers

4. Reduce the risk of a cancer returning in the same breast by 30-40 per cent in pre-menopausal women; and by 40 to 50 per cent in post-menopausal women who are ER+

5. Reduce the risk of a cancer appearing in the other breast by 50 per cent


The Possible side-effects of Tamoxifen

At the same time as blocking oestrogen´s action in breast cells, it appears to stimulate its action in liver and bone cells! On the positive side, there are claims that it can stop bone loss in older women, and even lower your cholesterol!

A number of doctors now prescribe bisphosphonate drugs to women who are clear of spread to the bones. US research shows that this strengthens the bones, and reduces the spread of breast cancer, whilst increasing survival.

Tamoxifen is not without controversy. In icon magazine´s Cancer Watch (which publishes the latest research from all over the world) over the last 8 years we have covered, for example:

        1. That four-fifths of US women who have the side effects fully explained to them, subsequently do not want to take it as a preventative agent (Cancer, 2005)

        2. That researchers in the UK concluded it should not be used as a preventative agent, the risks outweighing the benefits

        3. That tamoxifen´s effects stay with you for 5 years after the end of usage (J Nat Can Inst 2007; 99, 272-282)

        4. That tamoxifen can increase the chances of endometrial cancer three-fold (Int Journal Gyn Cancer 2007)

        5. That tamoxifen usage for 5 or more years can cause a more dangerous ER-ve cancer in the other breast (Cancer Research online August 2009)

As if that was not enough, recent research studies have shown that the common view of how it works is not entirely correct. In fact,  many authoritative bodies didn´t really know how it worked anyway. For example, Cancer Research UK (December 2008) stated,  Previously, it was known that tamoxifen worked by blocking oestrogen from causing unchecked cell growth in breast tissue............. by switching certain genes on........ but the mechanism by which this occurred was unknown. Hardly reassuring to users, and difficult to understand how it was originally approved if we didn´t know how it worked. Herbalists have been called quacks for less.

A big concern has been tamoxifen resistance which can develop in some women users and no one seems to know why. The CRUK statement above prefaced a study by CRUK Cambridge Research Institute workers into the problem. They discovered (Nature, Dec 2008) for the first time the mechanism by which tamoxifen operates. It switches off a breast cancer gene ErbB2 via a protein Pax2, which keeps it off. Tamoxifen resistence occurs when the gene is on.

Other research studies covered in Cancer Watch have suggested that tamoxifen can itself cause genetic mutation.

On the knotty problem of tamoxifen resistance German Researchers seem to have shed some light too. Researchers from three German Universities have shown that Electromagnetic Fields (thought by many to be capable of causing breast cancer) can result in a lower sensitivity to tamoxifen. The researchers were convinced that EMFs reduce the efficacy of tamoxifen.

Also identified has been the need for an enzyme (CYP2D6) to convert the drug tamoxifen to its active form. In about 10 per cent of cases this conversion doesn´t happen. It can be worsened by certain drugs such as Prozac and other anti-depressants (SSRIs and SNRIs) and drugs like Benedryl. You must check out all other medications they might stop your tamoxifen working.

Side effects can include: hot flushes, irregular menstrual cycles, unusual vaginal discharge or bleeding, irritation of skin around vagina.

There can be increased risk of blood clots, cancer of the womb lining (endometriosis) and an increased risk of stroke or thrombi-embolism.

6 per cent of women on tamoxifen report impaired vision due to cornea and retina damage.

Astra Zeneca has reported it can cause liver damage and there is a 6-fold increase in the risk of liver cancer. So, technically, it is actually a carcinogen and in 1996 was declared one by the World Health Organisation. The National Health and Medical Research Council in Australia has reported that there is no safe dose to reduce risk of liver cancer.

Developments: US research showed that the use of natural vitamin E (especially tocotrienols) meant 25 per cent less tamoxifen needed to be prescribed. Similar research has shown that indole 3 carbinol supplementation means less drug is needed for the same positive effect.

Usage: Tamoxifen is taken orally in tablet form or in a sugar-free syrup. Most doctors recommended it is taken at the same time each day. Other pages you might like to read

 If you are thinking of buying indole 3 carbinol you might like to look at the Natural Selection Product of Choice. You can do this by  clicking here.

 

Herceptin

Natural Alternatives to Aromatase Inhibitors

Indole3carbinol

Red Clover

Omega 3

 

Other articles that you may find interesting are:


  1. Diet for Chemotherapy ;

  2. Beneficial bacteria ;

  3. A-Z guide to complementary therapies;

  4. Your cancer, where you can read about everything from causes to cancer treatments to complementary therapies for your cancer.

  5. How to boost your immune system.

To return to the drug list, click here.

Learn about your cancer drugs.
CancerAcitve Logo
Subscribe (Free e-Newsletter)

Join Our
Newsletter

Join Our Newsletter Signup today for free and be the first to get notified on new updates.